The Independent Pizzeria
The Independent Pizzeria is a restaurant provider in Indianapolis, IN serving Indianapolis and surrounding areas. The Independent Pizzeria is a family-owned establishment located in Madison Park, offering a cozy and chill space for pizza enthusiasts. Contact The Independent Pizzeria for a free estimate.
About The Independent Pizzeria
The Independent Pizzeria is a family-owned establishment located in Madison Park, offering a cozy and chill space for pizza enthusiasts. Their menu features a variety of pizzas, salads, and specials, all made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Signature dishes include their unique 'Pizza Porn' creations and daily specials, all served in a relaxed, community-focused atmosphere. The restaurant operates on a to-go basis, with orders available by phone, online, or in person.
17 years in business
Services
Catering
FeaturedCustom catering for corporate events, parties, and private gatherings. Minimum order applies.
Starting at $24 / per person
Pizza Dine-In
FeaturedFull table service in our dining room. Reservations recommended on weekends.
Starting at $30 / per person
Happy Hour
Daily specials on drinks and appetizers. Check our current menu for details and times.
Starting at $12 / per item
Private Events
Reserve our private dining room or full venue for special occasions and corporate functions.
Starting at $1194 / per event
Takeout & Delivery
Order your pizza for carryout or delivery. We deliver hot and fresh within 30 minutes.
Starting at $16 / per order
Location
Madison Park
Indianapolis, IN 46227
Hours of Operation
Services Offered
Catering
Custom catering for corporate events, parties, and private gatherings. Minimum order applies.
$24
starting at
Pizza Dine-In
Full table service in our dining room. Reservations recommended on weekends.
$30
starting at
Happy Hour
Daily specials on drinks and appetizers. Check our current menu for details and times.
$12
starting at
Private Events
Reserve our private dining room or full venue for special occasions and corporate functions.
$1,194
starting at
Takeout & Delivery
Order your pizza for carryout or delivery. We deliver hot and fresh within 30 minutes.
$16
starting at
Reviews
4.7
7 reviews
7 reviews
Daniel P.
The Neapolitan pizza at The Independent Pizzeria is cooked in a wood-fired oven at 900 degrees and comes out perfectly charred and chewy. Best pizza in Indianapolis without question.
19 people found this helpful
Response from The Independent Pizzeria
Thank you so much for the wonderful review! We work hard every day to deliver the best dining experience in Indianapolis and it means everything to hear feedback like this. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Stephanie Y.
The Independent Pizzeria has mastered the Detroit-style pizza. Crispy caramelized cheese edges, thick focaccia crust, and generous toppings. Completely different from regular pizza and absolutely delicious.
12 people found this helpful
Response from The Independent Pizzeria
We are so glad you enjoyed your visit to The Independent Pizzeria! Your kind words motivate our entire team. Please come back and try our seasonal specials!
Tyler J.
The pizza dough at The Independent Pizzeria is fermented for 72 hours and the difference is remarkable. Light, airy, with great flavor. The fresh mozzarella and San Marzano tomatoes seal the deal.
5 people found this helpful
Response from The Independent Pizzeria
Thank you so much for the wonderful review! We work hard every day to deliver the best dining experience in Indianapolis and it means everything to hear feedback like this. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Maria L.
Family pizza night at The Independent Pizzeria every Friday. The kids love building their own and the staff is patient and fun. Great atmosphere and the pizza is genuinely excellent for Indianapolis.
6 people found this helpful
Chris H.
The white pizza with truffle oil and arugula at The Independent Pizzeria is something special. Creative toppings, quality ingredients, and a crust that is perfectly crispy on the bottom and chewy inside.
13 people found this helpful
Response from The Independent Pizzeria
Thank you so much for the wonderful review! We work hard every day to deliver the best dining experience in Indianapolis and it means everything to hear feedback like this. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Nicole A.
Solid pizza spot in Indianapolis. The Independent Pizzeria has consistent quality, good sauce, and generous portions. The garlic knots are addictive and the delivery is always on time.
4 people found this helpful
Ryan I.
The Independent Pizzeria is the locals' pizza secret in Indianapolis. No fancy marketing, just incredible pizza made by people who love what they do. The grandma-style square slice is not to be missed.
5 people found this helpful
Response from The Independent Pizzeria
Thank you for sharing your experience! We love welcoming guests to The Independent Pizzeria and are thrilled you enjoyed the food. See you next time!
Location
Indianapolis, IN 46227
Frequently Asked Questions
Last updated April 2026