Nancy's Pizza
About Nancy's Pizza
Nancy's Pizza in New Lenox specializes in Chicago's iconic stuffed and thin-crust pizzas, using time-honored recipes and the freshest ingredients. Their Original Stuffed Pizza, featuring a blend of cheeses and a flavorful tomato sauce, is a standout. The restaurant also offers pastas, appetizers, salads, and desserts, all in a welcoming atmosphere. With a legacy since 1971, Nancy's continues to be a go-to spot for pizza enthusiasts in the area.
17 years in business
Services
Catering
FeaturedCustom catering for corporate events, parties, and private gatherings. Minimum order applies.
Starting at $28 / per person
Dine-In
FeaturedFull table service in our dining room. Reservations recommended on weekends.
Starting at $22 / per person
Happy Hour
Daily specials on drinks and appetizers. Check our current menu for details and times.
Starting at $12 / per item
Private Events
Reserve our private dining room or full venue for special occasions and corporate functions.
Starting at $1618 / per event
Takeout & Delivery
Order online or by phone for pickup or local delivery. Same menu, same quality.
Starting at $20 / per order
Location
1840 E Lincoln Highway
New Lenox, IL 60451
Hours of Operation
Services Offered
Catering
Custom catering for corporate events, parties, and private gatherings. Minimum order applies.
$28
starting at
Dine-In
Full table service in our dining room. Reservations recommended on weekends.
$22
starting at
Happy Hour
Daily specials on drinks and appetizers. Check our current menu for details and times.
$12
starting at
Private Events
Reserve our private dining room or full venue for special occasions and corporate functions.
$1,618
starting at
Takeout & Delivery
Order online or by phone for pickup or local delivery. Same menu, same quality.
$20
starting at
Reviews
4.7
7 reviews
7 reviews
Brian E.
Nancy's Pizza has the most authentic pasta I have had outside of Italy. The carbonara is made tableside and the portions are generous. Great wine list too. New Lenox is lucky to have this place.
23 people found this helpful
Response from Nancy's Pizza
Thank you so much for the wonderful review! We work hard every day to deliver the best dining experience in New Lenox and it means everything to hear feedback like this. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Megan U.
Ordered the lasagna and tiramisu at Nancy's Pizza and both were outstanding. The sauce is housemade and you can taste the difference. Cozy atmosphere, great for date night.
4 people found this helpful
Response from Nancy's Pizza
We are so glad you enjoyed your visit to Nancy's Pizza! Your kind words motivate our entire team. Please come back and try our seasonal specials!
Aaron M.
I have been to a lot of Italian places in New Lenox and Nancy's Pizza is at the top. Fresh ingredients, perfect al dente pasta, and the bread service is complimentary. Highly recommend.
9 people found this helpful
Response from Nancy's Pizza
Thank you so much for the wonderful review! We work hard every day to deliver the best dining experience in New Lenox and it means everything to hear feedback like this. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Ashley W.
The wood-fired pizza at Nancy's Pizza is worth the drive. Thin crust, quality toppings, and the bruschetta appetizer is a must-order. Service was attentive and friendly.
6 people found this helpful
Kevin O.
Family dinner at Nancy's Pizza was a hit. Kids loved the pizza, adults loved the house Chianti. Prices are fair for the quality. Will be our new Italian spot in New Lenox.
5 people found this helpful
Response from Nancy's Pizza
Thank you so much for the wonderful review! We work hard every day to deliver the best dining experience in New Lenox and it means everything to hear feedback like this. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Emily V.
Decent Italian food at Nancy's Pizza. The penne arrabbiata had a nice kick and the cannoli was fresh. A bit noisy on weekends but the food makes up for it.
2 people found this helpful
Nathan C.
Stumbled upon Nancy's Pizza and so glad we did. The owners are from Naples and it shows in every dish. Authentic ingredients, reasonable prices for New Lenox.
9 people found this helpful
Response from Nancy's Pizza
Thank you for sharing your experience! We love welcoming guests to Nancy's Pizza and are thrilled you enjoyed the food. See you next time!
Location
New Lenox, IL 60451
Frequently Asked Questions
Last updated April 2026
Similar Businesses in New Lenox
Related
Related Restaurant in New Lenox
HAROLD'S CHICKEN
Restaurant in New Lenox
Rosati'S Pizza
Pizza in New Lenox
Williamson's Restaurant and Bar
Restaurant in New Lenox
Senso
Restaurant in New Lenox
Smokin' Z BBQ
Restaurant in New Lenox
Fox and Turtle
Restaurant in New Lenox
Loop Thai Kitchen
Restaurant in New Lenox
Gianni's Ristorante and Pizzeria
Restaurant in New Lenox
Peking Cajun Seafood
Asian Fusion in New Lenox
Lulu Belle's Pancake House
Restaurant in New Lenox
Lazy Moe's
Greek in New Lenox
Country Charm Restaurant
Restaurant in New Lenox
Rising Sun
Restaurant in New Lenox
Estrella Taco Restaurant
Restaurant in New Lenox
Dragon Palace
Restaurant in New Lenox
Other Trusted Businesses in New Lenox
Discover more verified local businesses near Nancy's Pizza.